|
Poslao: 07 Sep 2010 16:47
|
offline
- Pridružio: 07 Avg 2008
- Poruke: 2528
- Gde živiš: VII kat
|
Plagijat kao umetnička forma?
Demijen Herst, britanski umetnik širom sveta poznat po tome što je ajkulu u formalinu i lobanju optočenu dijamantima uspeo da skupo proda kao umetnost, ponovo je optužen za plagijat. Njegov kolega, Čarls Tomson, poznat po oštrim kritikama upućenim jednom delu britanske savremene umetničke scene, objavio je članak u časopisu Jackdaw art, u kom Hersta optužuje za učestalo prisvajanje tuđih ideja kao svojih.
Citat:Charles Thomson, the artist and co-founder of the Stuckists, a group campaigning for traditional artistry, collated the number of plagiarism claims relating to Hirst's work for the latest issue of the Jackdaw art magazine.
He came up with 15 examples, with eight said to be new instances of plagiarism. The tally includes the medicine cabinets that Hirst first displayed in 1989, and its development in 1992 - a room-size installation called Pharmacy.
"Joseph Cornell displayed a cabinet with bottles on shelves called Pharmacy in 1943," said Thomson. Nor were Hirst's spin paintings or his installation of a ball on a jet of air original, he said, noting that both were done in the 1960s.
"Hirst puts himself forward as a great artist, but a lot of his work exists only because other artists have come up with original ideas which he has stolen," said Thomson. "Hirst is a plagiarist in a way that would be totally unacceptable in science or literature."
...
Aggrieved artists include John LeKay, a Briton who says he first thought of nailing a lamb's carcass to wood like a cross in 1987, only to see it reproduced by Hirst. Lekay previously claimed in 2007 that he had been producing jewel-encrusted skulls since 1993, before Hirst did so. Lori Precious, an American, says she first arranged butterfly wings into patterns to suggest stained-glass windows in 1994, years before Hirst.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/artanddesign/2010/sep/02.....ism-claims
Herst se sa sličnim optužbama susreće od 1999. godine. Herstov kolega, i nekadašnji prijatelj, Džon Lekej, ukazao je i 2007. godine na sličnost između svojih i Herstovih radova.
 
Džon Lekej, Spiritus Calidus, 1993.
Demijen Herst, For the Love of God, 2007.
|
|
|
|
|
Registruj se da bi učestvovao u diskusiji. Registrovanim korisnicima se NE prikazuju reklame unutar poruka.
|
|
|
Poslao: 07 Sep 2010 21:20
|
offline
- Ričard
- Lavlje srce
- Supermoderator
- Zver!
- Electro maintenance engineer
- Pridružio: 28 Nov 2006
- Poruke: 13745
- Gde živiš: Vršac
|
jelkica7 ::Demijen Herst, britanski umetnik širom sveta poznat po tome što je ajkulu u formalinu i lobanju optočenu dijamantima uspeo da skupo proda kao umetnost, ponovo je optužen za plagijat...
Eeee, kada bi ja imao tu moć da maglu prodajem kao nešto vredno, gde bi mi bio kraj? 
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Poslao: 07 Sep 2010 21:41
|
offline
- Pridružio: 07 Avg 2008
- Poruke: 2528
- Gde živiš: VII kat
|
Ričard ::Eeee, kada bi ja imao tu moć da maglu prodajem kao nešto vredno, gde bi mi bio kraj?
Ko ti kriv što nisi umetnik. Nemoj samo da se pravdaš kako ne umeš da slikaš. 
Damien Hirst ::He shakes his head. "No, I don't believe in genius. I believe in freedom. I think anyone can do it. Anyone can be like Rembrandt."
Hirst is a master of the potty soundbite. I wait for a smile or wink, but it doesn't come. Instead, he gets into his philosophical stride. "Picasso, Michelangelo, possibly, might be verging on genius, but I don't think a painter like Rembrandt is a genius. It's about freedom and guts. It's about looking. It can be learned. That's the great thing about art. Anybody can do it if you just believe. With practice, you can make great paintings."
http://www.guardian.co.uk/artanddesign/2009/nov/14/damien-hirst-interview
Svako može da nauči da slika, ali da uspešno krade ideje, jok!  
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Poslao: 08 Sep 2010 12:19
|
offline
- Wraith
- Ugledni građanin
- Pridružio: 22 Jun 2006
- Poruke: 409
|
Citat:n 2003, under the title A Dead Shark Isn't Art, the Stuckism International Gallery exhibited a shark which had first been put on public display two years before Hirst's by Eddie Saunders in his Shoreditch shop, JD Electrical Supplies. Thomson asked, "If Hirst’s shark is recognised as great art, then how come Eddie’s, which was on exhibition for two years beforehand, isn’t? Do we perhaps have here an undiscovered artist of genius, who got there first, or is it that a dead shark isn’t art at all?"[81] The Stuckists suggested that Hirst may have got the idea for his work from Saunders' shop display.[82]
Izvor: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Damien_Hirst#Negative
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Poslao: 02 Sep 2012 03:29
|
offline
- Pridružio: 07 Avg 2008
- Poruke: 2528
- Gde živiš: VII kat
|
Napisano: 09 Sep 2010 13:31
Simke ::Ili ti, ma svi su oni plagijatori, manje-vise ...
Npr:
 
Ovakve pozajmice su uobičajene za velike umetnike, nisu nikakav izuzetak. Problem originalnog u umetnosti se često pogrešno percipira, i precenjuje. Problem je, kako ja to razumem, u tome što Herst ne priznaje prave izvore svoje inspiracije. (To jest Ćele-kulu, u slučaju "For the Love of God". )
Ako originalnost i inspiraciju ostavimo po strani, i dalje smo slobodni da se zapitamo da li je pred nama umetnost, ili nije. Na to će, bojim se, svako za sebe morati da odgovori.
Dopuna: 02 Sep 2012 3:29
Dve godine kasnije, Herst otvoreno govori o uticajima drugih na njegovu umetnost. Nedavno "priznao" uticaj dečije emisije iz sedamdesetih, "Blue Peter", na njegove "vrteće" slike. Samo, problem je sada količina gluposti koju je usput uspeo da izgovori.
Citat:He tells kids that at first he assumed the spin machine was just fun, "whereas art is something more serious. And then as I got older, I started thinking about Van Gogh and all those painters, and cutting your ear off when you're painting, and at that point I just thought: 'Why does it have to be like that?' I thought: 'No, actually, the better art is the art made with the spin machine.'"
Izvor: http://www.guardian.co.uk/artanddesign/jonathanjon.....l-disgrace
Video: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-19399198
|
|
|
|
|
|
